Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I seem to be in a huge minority, but I think Zed is right on here (and in many other places).


You're not in the minority. Fanatics are just loud. Zed is the odd man out by being both loud and non-fanatical about licenses.

We have projects under both licenses, representing a half million lines of code, and I rarely rant about licenses.


> You're not in the minority. Fanatics are just loud.

Hmmm. That statement has implications you may not have intended.


I'm not really sure it is a minority, or at least not as much as it may seem here on Hacker News. I recall reading that the GPL is by far the single most popular open source license. Can't seem to be able to back it up though.

Either way, something like 25% of projects listed on ohloh are licensed under the GPL, so its hardly a small minority of the free software community.


Several licenses are typically lumped together as BSD-like licenses, especially when comparing to the GPL. How about when the numbers for the BSD, 3-clause BSD, MIT, ISC, etc. are combined? (Counting the GPL is likewise combining GPL v. 2, GPL v. 3, LGPL, etc., I expect.)


That's an incorrect number. If you look at the open source code on the internet, it hovers around 47% to 48% (with a greater than 2b unique project lines sample.

About 22% are lgpl, though, so maybe that's what you meant.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: