Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Great book -- read it when I was a teenager -- but one thing that I think makes the book a bit harder to explain to smaller kids these days is the use of relays for explaining lots of things. Its a great concept to explain things but it does tend to cause a bit of confusing for younger kids who may not have played with electromagnets as much as kids from 20-30 years ago. Not sure what to replace relays with but maybe having kids watch a super easy to understand video about how relays work would help make the book easier to understand for say like an 8 year old reading the book.


Hydraulic relays? I vaguely remember coming across a similar "bottom-up" book about how computers work many decades ago (near the end of the mainframe/minicomputer era) which used water flowing through pipes and valves as its analogy. Unfortunately the title wasn't so memorable, but I do recall the cover was a photo of a little girl filling a bucket from a spigot on the outside of a house. Does anyone know what book that was? I've searched a bit before, but had no luck.


My kids played a lot with "relays" in Minecraft using Redstone. Not quite the same, though!


Ha that's a great idea.. sounds like a good idea for a coding book.. hey so you know minecraft.. use that knowledge to learn how computers work..


very easily substitute using FETs. Essentially the same as relays and BJTs but much easier to control logic FETs than BJTs.


But that would introduce more complexity (polarity, biasing, etc) that would distract from the initial purpose. With a relay they should only learn how connecting a battery to pins 1 and 2 closes the contacts on 3 and 4. Using relays with more throws they can also learn the basics of logic gates, flip flops, etc. I believe that relays still have a place for educational purposes.


Yup! Agree 100%




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: