Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Thank you for the interesting analysis and link. It seems that the issues are:

  * SEC registration is meant to protect investors.

  * SEC registration is so expensive only large corporations can
    afford it.

  * Companies can be exempt from the SEC registration requirement if
    everyone who purchases their securities meets certain minimum
    net worth or income requirements (this does not apply to
    35 purchasers, which apparently need meet no minimum standard
    at all).  Purchasers who meet these minimum requirements
    are called "accredited investors".

  * The justification for allowing the accredited investment
    exemption seems to be a desire to allow investment while at
    the same time recognizing that certain well-off investors don't
    need the protection SEC registration offers.

  * The threshold for being an accredited investor is being raised.
My own responses and concerns about all this are:

  * Is it really true that SEC registration is so expensive that
    only large corporations can afford it?  Just how expensive is
    it?  Why is it so expensive?  Can the expense be made any more
    affordable for smaller companies?

  * What rationale is being used to justify setting the threshold
    for being an "accredited investor" at any level whatsoever?
    What makes investors worth $1 million any more able to do
    without the protection provided by SEC registration any more
    than an investor who is worth only $500,000?  Given what we've
    seen in the recent financial crisis (where even the wealthiest
    investors suffered or even went bankrupt), isn't it clear that
    even wealthy investors need more protection?

  * Does SEC registration of any given corporation really only
    protect the direct investors in that corporation?  Or does SEC
    registration benefit society and the economy as a whole?
    Perhaps we should be thinking of ways to make more corporations
    subject to SEC registration, not less.  If this can be done in a
    way that smaller corporations can afford, why not?


Dude, when you're 3 dudes living in an apartment with no money, any govt regulation is painful and harmful to progress.


How about regulations that keep you from doing stupid or illegal things or defrauding the people who invest in your company?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: