> The biggest problem with these tools is scalability and maintainability.
This has been my biggest complaint with both Unreal and NI Reactor... you can build some brilliant things, but not without creating a mess of connections that becomes very difficult to reason about, let alone work on. A lot of production "visual programming" diagrams are spaghetti code, without comments or a changelog you can study.
While written code tends to the same way (just try diagramming the class tree in most software), at least we have tools for dealing with and reasoning about it in text form.
Indeed, spaghetti is a big deal. However, in systems like [Node-Red, Antimony, Apache NiFi] you can make function nodes that abstract out the actual data vs the function. And then, your function primitive can be called and instantiated for the particular purposes.
I know in Antimony CAD, you can even instantiate a function, edit the function's flow or individual python subroutines, and the delta is saved for that instance.
I know the hardest graphical programming I've had was with the Lego Mindstorms ev3. There were multiple "simplifications" that removed functions along with a nigh-unusable gui (the if block was this huge encapsulating thing, and other branch codes also had onerous things on screen).
the tools for reasoning about text can be limited if the text is in a language unsuitable for reasoning
this is why we work in a typed, purely functional setting.
spaghetti is difficult to deal with, for starters, you need "compositionality", so that you get no undefined or emergent behaviour.
then second you need some form of "graphical macros", or a "meta-language" for diagrams, code that generates diagrams or "higher order functions" for diagrams.
This has been my biggest complaint with both Unreal and NI Reactor... you can build some brilliant things, but not without creating a mess of connections that becomes very difficult to reason about, let alone work on. A lot of production "visual programming" diagrams are spaghetti code, without comments or a changelog you can study.
While written code tends to the same way (just try diagramming the class tree in most software), at least we have tools for dealing with and reasoning about it in text form.