Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You must being living in a very different community than mine. I live in Texas and being a heroin/cocaine/alcohol/nicotine(not as much) addict is a shameful thing. Yet we still have quiet the drug problem.

I've only known a few people who fell down the deadly spiral of drug abuse. But each one hid their addiction because of shame until it was so terrible they couldn't. And I believe if it had been less shameful they might have gotten support before they completely ruined their lives.



I live close enough and here's my observation.

There is a very large subgroup that doesn't regard these things as shameful. This often becomes the main group of people involved with drugs. And it keeps sucking them back in, sometimes when they would otherwise get and this is exactly the problem I'm talking about.


Have you considered that a large part of the reason it keeps sucking them back in might be that it's the only environment where they're not judged for their problem?

If so, a less judgemental environment might very well help more people out of the addiction cycle, and a more judgemental environment might very well make it harder to escape.

It's not at all clear that making it into something shameful has any positive effects.


In the US, bible belt culture generally regards drugs as shameful, and yet, this is where heroin and meth abuse is most prevalent. Same with porn use, drug use's cousin. Less shaming leads to the same levels or less than if their were shaming because, counterintuitively enough, shame and blame increases isolation and foul moods which leads to more drug use than otherwise would exist.

Best for anti-drug folks to take some responsibility for creating this "war on drugs", its attendant culture and the lives lost.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: